Promise Not to Tell

I just stayed up all night to finish this book. The second I've read by this author. A really great read, there were several times I thought I had figured it out, but I was wrong. Definitely recommend!

Jennifer McMahon's debut novel is impressive and showcases the author's narrative skill. The story centers around protagonist Kate Cypher, who returns to her childhood home in New Canaan in 2002, and finds herself revisiting memories of the past, way back in 1971 when a girl Del Griswold, nicknamed the Potato Girl is found murdered. Interestingly, and ominously, a murder takes place in the present, also involving a young girl, Tori. The story weaves back and forth between the past and present,but it never seems disjointed. Instead, it makes for a compelling read...not to give too much away, there are various themes explored here, such as bullying, child abuse, betrayal, and even a supernatural element. It could have been confusing, instead the author skillfully weaves a thought-provoking, intriguing story that will hold you spellbound.

I read this book in two day, making time for it, even though I didn't really have the time. From the first few pages, I was hooked. Both main character (in the past and present) were identifiable and enjoyable. I'll recommend this book to my reading group, and others I know that enjoy this genre (and even those who normally don't), as it transcends both the ghost story and "coming-of-age" labels.

I read this in 2 goes. What a tale of mystery this is! Once you get used to the jumping of dates, it becomes a seamless read that will leave you wanting more. I really loved the details about the "hippie" camp and life of "Potato Girl". This would also be a great book for older-teen mystery lovers that liked to be creeped out. I hope to see more from this author in the future.

I can't even remember the last time that I read a book as multi-faceted as "Promise Not To Tell." Within the span of just 250 pages, I was seriously frightened. And then laughing. Followed by a lump in my throat. Finished off by a darn good mystery. I am going to recommend this book to everyone I know. I can't stop thinking about it even now. You will never meet a more unforgettable character than Delores Griswold. I was scared both for her and by her. Jennifer McMahon, I'll be remembering your name in the future! Wonderful!

I really really REALLY liked Promise Not to Tell! I got it yesterday morning and read it in two sittings, staying up way too late last night! Like a great ghost story, it is truly creepy and atmospheric. Like a great whodunit, it is suspenseful and keeps you guessing. Like a great "literary" novel, it is very moving (sometimes heartbreaking) and somehow feels "true." Although Del, the Potato Girl, is definitely the star of the show, I thought all the other characters were complex and well-drawn. Kate, the narrator for most of the book has a great voice: wry, regretful, and totally believable. I also have a real soft spot for Nicky Griswold and worry about what's going to become of him! All in all, an awesome debut -- highly recommended!