MacArthur's Jungle War: The 1944 New Guinea Campaign (Modern War Studies)

Outstanding coverage of MacArthur's 1944 New Guinea campaign covering the units and personalities involved at the strategic, operational, and tactical level. I would give it 5 stars except the maps have no scale, which is extremely frustrating. Also, more precise topographic detail on the maps would distinctly aid understanding. Maybe next edition...

Taaffe provides much needed depth to the subject. I will not go as far to say the coverage is complete, but Jungle War is generally the most useful volumes on the subject out in recent years. I felt the author correctly split his narrative from the early stages of the campaign using the invasion of the Admiralties in perspective. Previous actions were linked more to the strategic directives from Washington to secure Australia's defense and isolate Rabaul. Sending the 1st Cavalry to the Admiralties, as Taaffe brings out, marked a departure onto the trail to Leyte. We are given good insight into the combat action down to in many cases the company level. As many actions in the SW Pacific hung on small units (in many cases squad, platoon and company), in much contrast to battles in the ETO, this is refreshing. We are also given brief discussions of key leaders and staff officer's personalities. However I would like to see more linkage between such and the much documented friction with MacArthur many experienced. The author provides a very good time line and exhausting bibliography. His endnotes are worth consulting throughout the read and provide detail beyond the narrative. However, I must complain to the publisher about the maps. Overall, while the subject probably requires 100 or more pages of text to fully document, the author does well. In the end we are poised to return to the Philippines with a grasp of the trials and tribulations of the SW Pacific command. The author links actions in the campaign to lessons learned and applied later in the war.

A seminal book about a WWII campaign that achieved nothing of strategic significance except to boost Gen. MacArthur's personal standing as well as diverting US military forces from a direct thrust at Japan. Oddly enough, only military operations from after Operation Cartwheel, which included the bloody Buna campaign, is covered. Interested readers on the related Australian operations including the Kokoda trail, as well as follow-on operations in the Philippines will have to look elsewhere. A clear prerequisite for reading and enjoying this book is to have read "American Caesar" by William Manchester which gives the background to the complex relationships between all the personalities involved. The almost deadly duel between MacArthur and Admiral King over overall strategy and logistics is highlighted, with Admiral Nimitz being pushed into the background. The race between MacArthur's and Nimitz's rival thrusts towards the Japanese Empire being one of the main themes here. The book constantly harps on MacArthur's obsession with getting back to the Philippines. Thus, in his race to beat the US Navy to the China-Luzon-Formosa area, MacArthur is criticised for moving too fast up the northern coast of PNG before securing his bases for staging the next amphibious landings. He doesn't appear to have endeared himself to the men doing the fighting but achieved his objectives in record time and with remarkably low casualty rates for the whole campaign. As MacArthur did not know about the Manhattan Project, he cannot be faulted for his strategic planning based largely on the then known technology as well as current US military capability. As it was, the atomic bombs were the strategic weapons that decisively ended the Pacific War. This remarkable book goes somewhere towards setting the record straight and giving due credit to the many forgotten servicemen who performed gallantly or gave their lives in this little-known campaign. The maps are clear, concise and relate well to the text.