It's My Church and I'll Stay If I Want to: Affirming Catholicism

Like the author, I grew up in a Catholic home and like the author, I left Catholicism as a young adult. This is the second book by this author (the other was actually co-authored with a monk) that I have read recently. I bought this one because I find the writing style compelling, mostly though she is honest about her doubts and about being a person who claims to have faith. Unlike the author, I have not returned to Catholicism and I can't say that this book has changed that. I don't think she's in denial or anything, I just don't agree that the institution as it stands today can or should be saved. Whether or not I agree with Ms. Collins Pratt, I very much like the book, her writing is memorable, poetic even. There is a lot in the book that gave me reason to pause, to think, to pray, to talk to others about what I was reading. This, I think, is what good spiritual writing should do rather than attempt to provide simple answers to difficult questions. One criticism, that doesn't reflect on the writer. I don't like the cover. The author does speak of being a little Catholic girl but the book is about more than that and the cover will probably keep some people from reading the book. Too bad.

I found this an enchanting book. shows the human dimension of catholicism. not only will it bring people back but it will make those of us who are still communicants happy with our religious commitment.

She's got me. I'm a good Baptist boy who thinks that any church that merits this kind of passion must have something going for it. Nothing is all black or white, nothing is perfect. Guess Catholics would appreciate and understand where the author is coming from better than I do but then again--none of them got to write the first review.Got to tell you what I liked most though. She is just a damned fine writer that is fun to read. You are sucked into her story on page one and wish it wouldn't end. Of course Catholics are going to be the ones buying this book most of the time. You don't have to be Catholic though to like the book. You will understand what makes Catholic Catholic to the people of that religion and you will understand why you are who you are too. I am frankly not sure which stays in my mind more, the sound of her writing voice or her message. Either way, she's a superb story-teller. I think this book will have a large audience because it is the kind of book people talk about.