Widow Nell is consumed by an unresolved mystery from her past-Jedidiah Shoneberger, an Amish man who vanished without a trace over forty years ago, mere weeks before their wedding. Overwhelmed by a mix of grief and lingering affection, she reaches out to Ettie Smith for assistance in piecing together the puzzle of Jedidiah's disappearance. Faced with the challenge of a cold case, Ettie finds an unexpected ally in her willful older sister,...