Tara finds herself at a crossroads, her heart pulled between two young men: one, a figure of quiet simplicity; the other, brimming with handsome confidence. When whispers from the Amish community suggest one of them may not be as he seems, Tara is faced with a dilemma. Can she look beyond appearances to make a choice that will shape her future? Who can she trust when her heart and her community's wisdom seem at odds?